base on An Easy-to-use, Scalable and High-performance RLHF Framework (70B+ PPO Full Tuning & Iterative DPO & LoRA & RingAttention & RFT) <div align="center"> <img alt="OpenRLHF logo" src="./docs/logo.png" style="height: 140px;" /> </div> <div align="center"> <p align="center"> <a href="https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF/graphs/contributors"> <img alt="GitHub Contributors" src="https://img.shields.io/github/contributors/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF" /> </a> <a href="https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF/issues"> <img alt="Issues" src="https://img.shields.io/github/issues/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF?color=0088ff" /> </a> <a href="https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF/discussions"> <img alt="Issues" src="https://img.shields.io/github/discussions/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF?color=0088ff" /> </a> <a href="https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF/pulls"> <img alt="GitHub pull requests" src="https://img.shields.io/github/issues-pr/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF?color=0088ff" /> <a href="https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF/stargazers"> <img alt="GitHub stars" src="https://img.shields.io/github/stars/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF?color=ccf" /> </a> <br> <em>Open-source / Comprehensive / Lightweight / Easy-to-use</em> </p> </p> </div> <hr> <span>[ English | <a href="README_zh.md">中文</a> ]</span> OpenRLHF is a high-performance RLHF framework built on Ray, DeepSpeed and HF Transformers: - **Simple and easy to use**: OpenRLHF is one of the simplest high-performance RLHF libraries currently available, and seamlessly compatible with Huggingface models and datasets. - **High performance**: RLHF training spends 80% of the time on the sample generation stage. Thanks to the ability to use a large inference batch size with Ray and Packing Samples and vLLM generation acceleration, the performance of OpenRLHF 3~4x+ that of Optimized DeepSpeedChat with Hybrid Engine. - **Distributed RLHF**: OpenRLHF distribute the Actor, Reward, Reference, and Critic models onto separate GPUs using Ray, while placing the Adam optimizer on the CPU. This enables full-scale fine-tuning of 70B+ models with multiple A100 80G GPUs and vLLM and 7B models across multiple 24GB RTX 4090 GPUs. - **PPO Implementation Optimization**: We integrated the implementation tricks for PPO to improve the training stability, referencing [Zhihu](https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/622134699) and the [Notion blog](https://hijkzzz.notion.site/rlhf-implementation-tricks?v=158d9a33ecc98132bf9e000c39227361). More details are in [Slides](https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1JRhB1d7csofx0PIZBmfyBdMluxNd5JLPpUHrrvVhGnk/edit?usp=sharing) | [Technical Report](https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11143) | [Documents](https://openrlhf.readthedocs.io/) ## News - [2024/12] We analyzed the PPO, REINFORCE, GRPO and RLOO in the [Notion Blogpost](https://hijkzzz.notion.site/unraveling-rlhf-and-its-variants-engineering-insights#147d9a33ecc9806090f3d5c749d31f05). ## Features - Distributed [PPO](./examples/scripts/train_ppo_llama_ray.sh) and [REINFORCE/RLOO](./examples/scripts/train_reinforce_llama_ray.sh) implementations based on Ray. - Full RLHF fine-tuning support for models with [over 70 billion parameters](./examples/scripts/train_ppo_llama_ray_70b.sh). - Integration with vLLM for accelerated generation in RLHF tasks (`--vllm_num_engines`). - Support for multiple reward models (`--reward_pretrain model1,model2...`) and remote reward models (`--remote_rm_url`). - Implementation of [DPO (Direct Preference Optimization)/IPO/cDPO](./examples/scripts/train_dpo_llama.sh) and [Kahneman-Tversky Optimization (KTO)](./examples/scripts/train_kto_llama.sh). - Support for [Iterative DPO](./examples/scripts/train_iterative_dpo_llama.sh) ([GitHub: Online-RLHF](https://github.com/RLHFlow/Online-RLHF)). - Support for [Rejection Sampling](./examples/scripts/train_rejection_sampling_llama.sh). - Implementation of [Conditional SFT](./examples/scripts/train_conditional_llama.sh) ([arXiv:2308.12050](https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12050)). - Support for [Knowledge Distillation](./examples/scripts/train_knowledge_distillation.sh) ([Microsoft: minillm](https://github.com/microsoft/LMOps/tree/main/minillm)). - Integration of [Process Reward Model (PRM)](./examples/scripts/train_prm_mistral.sh). - Packing of training samples for SFT, DPO, RM, PRM, and PPO (`--packing_samples`). - Implementation of [RingAttention](./examples/scripts/train_dpo_ring_llama.sh) (`--ring_attn_size`, `--ring_head_stride`). - Support for [Mixture of Experts (MoE)](./examples/test_scripts/train_sft_mixtral_lora.sh) (`--aux_loss_coef`). - Integration of FlashAttention2 (`--flash_attn`). - Support for QLoRA (`--load_in_4bit`) and [LoRA](./examples/scripts/train_sft_mixtral_lora.sh) (`--lora_rank`, `--target_modules`). - Compatibility with HuggingFace's `tokenizer.apply_chat_template` for datasets (`--apply_chat_template` and `--input_key`). - Logging support with Wandb (`--use_wandb`) and TensorBoard (`--use_tensorboard`). - Checkpoint recovery functionality (`--load_checkpoint` and `--save_steps`). - Provided multi-node training scripts, such as [DPO](./examples/scripts/train_llama_slurm.sh) and [Ray PPO](./examples/scripts/train_ppo_llama_ray_slurm.sh). ### PPO Support Matrix | Feature | OpenRLHF | DSChat | CAIChat | TRL | | ------------- |:-------------:| :-------------:| :-------------:| :-------------:| | 70B+ Full Tuning with 16 A100-80GB | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | | 7B Full Tuning with 4 RTX4090 | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | | 34B DPO Full Tuning with 8 A100-80GB | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | | Inference Engine in PPO | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | | PPO Implementation Tricks | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | | Support QLoRA | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | | Support Mixtral 8*7b | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | | Support Unmerged Actor-Critic | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ | | Support Multiple Reward Models | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | | Support Huggingface Models | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | | Easy-to-use | ✅ | ❌ (HybridEngine bugs) | ✅ | ✅ | ## Quick Start ### Installation To use OpenRLHF, first launch the docker container (**Recommended**) and `pip install` openrlhf inside the docker container: ```bash # Launch the docker container docker run --runtime=nvidia -it --rm --shm-size="10g" --cap-add=SYS_ADMIN -v $PWD:/openrlhf nvcr.io/nvidia/pytorch:24.07-py3 bash sudo pip uninstall xgboost transformer_engine flash_attn -y # pip install pip install openrlhf # If you want to use vLLM acceleration (Install vLLM 0.6.5) pip install openrlhf[vllm] # latest vLLM is also supported pip install openrlhf[vllm_latest] # pip install the latest version pip install git+https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF.git # Or git clone git clone https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF.git cd OpenRLHF pip install -e . ``` > [!NOTE] >We recommend using vLLM 0.6.4 or higher. Other versions (vLLM >= 0.4.2) may require weight synchronization via Gloo (`--vllm_sync_backend gloo`). >We also provided the [Dockerfiles for vLLM](./dockerfile/) and [One-Click Installation Script of Nvidia-Docker](./examples/scripts/nvidia_docker_install.sh). ### Prepare Datasets OpenRLHF provides multiple data processing methods in our dataset classes. Such as in the [Prompt Dataset](https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF/blob/main/openrlhf/datasets/prompts_dataset.py#L6): ```python def preprocess_data(data, input_template=None, input_key="input", apply_chat_template=None) -> str: if apply_chat_template: prompt = apply_chat_template(data[input_key], tokenize=False, add_generation_prompt=True) else: prompt = data[input_key] if input_template: prompt = input_template.format(prompt) return prompt ``` - We can use `--input_key` to specify the `JSON key name` of the input datasets `--prompt_data {name or path}` (PPO) or `--dataset {name or path}`, and use `--apply_chat_template` to utilize the `chat_template` from the [Huggingface Tokenizer](https://huggingface.co/docs/transformers/main/en/chat_templating). - If you don't want to use `--apply_chat_template`, you can use `--input_template` instead, or preprocess the datasets offline in advance. - OpenRLHF also support mixing multiple datasets using `--prompt_data_probs 0.1,0.4,0.5` (PPO) or `--dataset_probs 0.1,0.4,0.5`. How Chat Templating Works: ```python dataset = [{"input_key": [ {"role": "user", "content": "Hello, how are you?"}, {"role": "assistant", "content": "I'm doing great. How can I help you today?"}, {"role": "user", "content": "I'd like to show off how chat templating works!"}, ]}] tokenizer.apply_chat_template(dataset[0]["input_key"], tokenize=False) "<s>[INST] Hello, how are you? [/INST]I'm doing great. How can I help you today?</s> [INST] I'd like to show off how chat templating works! [/INST]" ``` How to specify training and test datasets ? You can specify it using the `data_type@data_dir` format. For example, the dataset can be set as `--dataset json@./data`. ``` data ├── test.jsonl └── train.jsonl ``` > [!NOTE] > By default, we use `train` and `test` as splits to distinguish training and testing datasets from Huggingface. > The ``JSON key`` options depends on the specific datasets. See [Reward Dataset](https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF/blob/main/openrlhf/datasets/reward_dataset.py#L10) and [SFT Dataset](https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF/blob/main/openrlhf/datasets/sft_dataset.py#L9) ### Supervised Fine-tuning OpenRLHF's model checkpoint is fully compatible with HuggingFace models. You can specify the model name or path using `--pretrain {name or path}`, `--reward_pretrain {name or path}` and `--critic_pretrain {name or path}`. We have provided some pre-trained checkpoints and datasets on [HuggingFace OpenRLHF](https://huggingface.co/OpenRLHF). Then you can use the startup scripts we provide in the [examples/scripts](./examples/scripts/) directory, or start the training using the following commands. ```bash deepspeed --module openrlhf.cli.train_sft \ --max_len 4096 \ --dataset Open-Orca/OpenOrca \ --input_key question \ --output_key response \ --input_template $'User: {}\nAssistant: ' \ --train_batch_size 256 \ --micro_train_batch_size 2 \ --max_samples 500000 \ --pretrain meta-llama/Meta-Llama-3-8B \ --save_path ./checkpoint/llama3-8b-sft \ --save_steps -1 \ --logging_steps 1 \ --eval_steps -1 \ --zero_stage 2 \ --max_epochs 1 \ --packing_samples \ --bf16 \ --flash_attn \ --learning_rate 5e-6 \ --gradient_checkpointing \ --use_wandb {wandb_token} # Support HF tokenizer.apply_chat_template # --apply_chat_template # --input_key {JSON Key} # --tokenizer_chat_template {HF Chat Template} # Support RingAttention # pip install ring_flash_attn # --ring_attn_size 2 \ # --ring_head_stride 2 \ # Can also be used for continued pre-training # --pretrain_mode ``` > [!NOTE] > OpenRLHF SFT/DPO/RewardModel/PPO trainers support `--packing_samples` [based on `--flash_attn`](https://github.com/MeetKai/functionary/tree/main/functionary/train/packing) ### Reward Model Training ```bash deepspeed --module openrlhf.cli.train_rm \ --save_path ./checkpoint/llama3-8b-rm \ --save_steps -1 \ --logging_steps 1 \ --eval_steps -1 \ --train_batch_size 256 \ --micro_train_batch_size 1 \ --pretrain OpenRLHF/Llama-3-8b-sft-mixture \ --bf16 \ --max_epochs 1 \ --max_len 8192 \ --zero_stage 3 \ --learning_rate 9e-6 \ --dataset OpenRLHF/preference_dataset_mixture2_and_safe_pku \ --apply_chat_template \ --chosen_key chosen \ --rejected_key rejected \ --flash_attn \ --packing_samples \ --gradient_checkpointing \ --use_wandb {wandb_token} ``` It is recommended to set the `--value_prefix_head` option of the Reward Model to `score`, so that we can load the model using `AutoModelForSequenceClassification`: ```python reward_model = AutoModelForSequenceClassification.from_pretrained( reward_model_path, num_labels=1, torch_dtype=torch.bfloat16, attn_implementation="flash_attention_2", use_cache=False, ) inputs = xxxx (Left Padding Input Tokens) reward = reward_model.model(*inputs) reward = reward_model.score(reward)[:, -1] ``` ### PPO without Ray ```bash deepspeed --module openrlhf.cli.train_ppo \ --pretrain OpenRLHF/Llama-3-8b-sft-mixture \ --reward_pretrain OpenRLHF/Llama-3-8b-rm-mixture \ --save_path ./checkpoint/llama-3-8b-rlhf \ --save_steps -1 \ --logging_steps 1 \ --eval_steps -1 \ --micro_train_batch_size 2 \ --train_batch_size 128 \ --micro_rollout_batch_size 4 \ --rollout_batch_size 1024 \ --max_epochs 1 \ --prompt_max_len 1024 \ --generate_max_len 1024 \ --zero_stage 2 \ --bf16 \ --actor_learning_rate 5e-7 \ --critic_learning_rate 9e-6 \ --init_kl_coef 0.01 \ --prompt_data OpenRLHF/prompt-collection-v0.1 \ --input_key context_messages \ --apply_chat_template \ --max_samples 100000 \ --normalize_reward \ --adam_offload \ --flash_attn \ --gradient_checkpointing \ --use_wandb {wandb_token} # Support remote reward model (HTTP) # --remote_rm_url http://localhost:5000/get_reward ``` ### PPO with Ray and vLLM To improve RLHF training speed or support 70B models, we can use the PPO with Ray and vLLM acceleration ```bash # launch the master node of ray in container ray start --head --node-ip-address 0.0.0.0 --num-gpus 8 # if you want to launch ray on more nodes, use ray start --address {MASTER-NODE-ADDRESS}:6379 --num-gpus 8 ray job submit --address="http://127.0.0.1:8265" \ --runtime-env-json='{"working_dir": "/openrlhf"}' \ -- python3 -m openrlhf.cli.train_ppo_ray \ --ref_num_nodes 1 \ --ref_num_gpus_per_node 2 \ --reward_num_nodes 1 \ --reward_num_gpus_per_node 2 \ --critic_num_nodes 1 \ --critic_num_gpus_per_node 2 \ --actor_num_nodes 1 \ --actor_num_gpus_per_node 2 \ --vllm_num_engines 2 \ --vllm_tensor_parallel_size 2 \ --colocate_critic_reward \ --colocate_actor_ref \ --pretrain OpenRLHF/Llama-3-8b-sft-mixture \ --reward_pretrain OpenRLHF/Llama-3-8b-rm-mixture \ --save_path /openrlhf/examples/checkpoint/llama3-8b-rlhf \ --micro_train_batch_size 8 \ --train_batch_size 128 \ --micro_rollout_batch_size 16 \ --rollout_batch_size 1024 \ --max_samples 100000 \ --max_epochs 1 \ --prompt_max_len 1024 \ --generate_max_len 1024 \ --zero_stage 3 \ --bf16 \ --actor_learning_rate 5e-7 \ --critic_learning_rate 9e-6 \ --init_kl_coef 0.01 \ --prompt_data OpenRLHF/prompt-collection-v0.1 \ --input_key context_messages \ --apply_chat_template \ --normalize_reward \ --packing_samples \ --adam_offload \ --flash_attn \ --gradient_checkpointing \ --use_wandb {wandb_token} # Support remote reward model (HTTP) # --remote_rm_url http://localhost:5000/get_reward # Support REINFORCE | RLOO # --advantage_estimator reinforce | rloo # Support N samples # --n_samples_per_prompt 4 ``` > [!NOTE] > Do not set `--vllm_num_engines` means not using the vLLM engine. > You can also use ``setup_commands`` to let Ray automatically deploy the environment, such as `--runtime-env-json='{"setup_commands": ["pip install openrlhf[vllm]"]}'`. > [!NOTE] > If you you encounter an error related to index out of range when deepspeed sets up the GPU devices, you can try to set the environment variable [`RAY_EXPERIMENTAL_NOSET_*_VISIBLE_DEVICES`](openrlhf/trainer/ray/utils.py) as a workaround. > ```bash > # For NVIDIA GPUs: > export RAY_EXPERIMENTAL_NOSET_CUDA_VISIBLE_DEVICES=1 > ``` The launch scripts and documents for supported algorithms are in [example/scripts](./examples/scripts/) and [Documents - Usage](https://openrlhf.readthedocs.io/en/latest/usage.html) ## Performance We optimized DSChat's performance to the greatest extent possible by employing techniques such as enabling Adam offload, along with reward model (RM) and reference model (Ref) offload to increase the micro-batch size during the inference stage and avoid out-of-memory issues. We even fixed some bugs in DSChat to enable the Hybrid Engine (HE) for LLaMA2. The average time (seconds) it took to train 1024 prompts with 1 PPO epoch using the Optimized DSChat and OpenRLHF: | **Size** | **NVIDIA A800-80GB GPUs** | **Optimized DSChat (with Hybrid Engine)** | **OpenRLHF** | **Speedup** | | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | | 7B | 16 | 855.09 | 471.11 | 1.82x | | 13B | 32 | 1528.93 | 608.93 | 2.5x | | 34B | 32 | 3634.98 | 1526.4 | 2.4x | | 70B | 32 | 10407.0 | 4488.53 | 2.3x | > [!NOTE] > The data is outdated; please refer to the performance tuning section for re-testing. ### Performance Tuning Guide To achieve optimal performance, we recommend allocating more nodes to the vLLM Engine. For example, for a 70B model with 32 A100 GPUs, it is advised to allocate 16 A100 GPUs to the vLLM Engine, 8 GPUs to the Actor model, and the remaining 8 GPUs to the Critic model. Additionally, enable the `--colocate_critic_reward`, `--colocate_actor_ref` options to merge nodes. Finally, you should increase the `rollout_micro_batch_size` (and minimize the TP size of vLLM engine) as much as possible. During the training phase, a larger `--micro_train_batch_size` is better and enable `--packing_samples`. When there are enough GPUs, please disable `--adam_offload` and enable `--overlap_comm`. For multi-nodes RLHF, please use `--vllm_sync_backend nccl` with vLLM 0.6.4+. ## Companies and Organizations using OpenRLHF - Google - ByteDance - Tencent - Alibaba - Baidu - China Telecom - Vivo - Allen AI - NexusFlow - Jülich Supercomputing Centre (JSC) - Berkeley Starling Team - M-A-P - ... ## Join Us **How to Join?** 1. Email us at [email protected] or join [GitHub Organization](https://github.com/OpenRLHF). Please include the following details: - Your name - Your GitHub username - Your areas of interest - Your skills and experience related to NLP and/or AI 1. You can also join us through the official GitHub [OpenRLHF ↗](https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF) project page. Just create an issue about your interest to contribute and we will get back to you. **What can you do?** 1. Join the team and participate in the development of the OpenRLHF project. 1. Contribute to the project by submitting pull requests. 1. Help improve documentation, fix bugs, or create new features. 1. Share the project and help us grow the community. ## Sponsor Us Your sponsorship can help us maintain and improve OpenRLHF. If you find this project useful, please consider sponsoring us. You can sponsor us on [Open Collective ↗](https://opencollective.com/OpenRLHF). ## Starchart [](https://star-history.com/#OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF&Date) ## Contributors A big thank you to all our contributors! If you want to contribute, feel free to make a pull request or create an issue. <a href="https://github.com/OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF/graphs/contributors"> <img src="https://contrib.rocks/image?repo=OpenRLHF/OpenRLHF" /> </a> ## References & Acknowledgements We would like to express our gratitude to the following projects and organizations for their contributions to the field of AI and NLP: - [Hugging Face Transformers ↗](https://github.com/huggingface/transformers) - [OpenAI GPT ↗](https://github.com/openai/gpt-3) - [LLaMA ↗](https://llama.meta.com/) - [DeepSpeed ↗](https://github.com/microsoft/DeepSpeed) - [Ray ↗](https://github.com/ray-project/ray) Our project would also like to thank [ColossalChat](https://github.com/hpcaitech/ColossalAI/tree/main/applications/Chat) and [DeepSpeedChat](https://github.com/microsoft/DeepSpeedExamples/tree/master/applications/DeepSpeed-Chat). In the early stages of the project, we referred to their code design. (2024/7) Our GitHub organization has changed from OpenLLMAI to OpenRLHF. ## Citation ``` @article{hu2024openrlhf, title={OpenRLHF: An Easy-to-use, Scalable and High-performance RLHF Framework}, author={Jian Hu and Xibin Wu and Zilin Zhu and Xianyu and Weixun Wang and Dehao Zhang and Yu Cao}, journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2405.11143}, year={2024} } ``` ______________________________________________________________________ *OpenRLHF © 2024 OpenRLHF. All Rights Reserved.* ", Assign "at most 3 tags" to the expected json: {"id":"5983","tags":[]} "only from the tags list I provide: [{"id":77,"name":"3d"},{"id":89,"name":"agent"},{"id":17,"name":"ai"},{"id":54,"name":"algorithm"},{"id":24,"name":"api"},{"id":44,"name":"authentication"},{"id":3,"name":"aws"},{"id":27,"name":"backend"},{"id":60,"name":"benchmark"},{"id":72,"name":"best-practices"},{"id":39,"name":"bitcoin"},{"id":37,"name":"blockchain"},{"id":1,"name":"blog"},{"id":45,"name":"bundler"},{"id":58,"name":"cache"},{"id":21,"name":"chat"},{"id":49,"name":"cicd"},{"id":4,"name":"cli"},{"id":64,"name":"cloud-native"},{"id":48,"name":"cms"},{"id":61,"name":"compiler"},{"id":68,"name":"containerization"},{"id":92,"name":"crm"},{"id":34,"name":"data"},{"id":47,"name":"database"},{"id":8,"name":"declarative-gui "},{"id":9,"name":"deploy-tool"},{"id":53,"name":"desktop-app"},{"id":6,"name":"dev-exp-lib"},{"id":59,"name":"dev-tool"},{"id":13,"name":"ecommerce"},{"id":26,"name":"editor"},{"id":66,"name":"emulator"},{"id":62,"name":"filesystem"},{"id":80,"name":"finance"},{"id":15,"name":"firmware"},{"id":73,"name":"for-fun"},{"id":2,"name":"framework"},{"id":11,"name":"frontend"},{"id":22,"name":"game"},{"id":81,"name":"game-engine "},{"id":23,"name":"graphql"},{"id":84,"name":"gui"},{"id":91,"name":"http"},{"id":5,"name":"http-client"},{"id":51,"name":"iac"},{"id":30,"name":"ide"},{"id":78,"name":"iot"},{"id":40,"name":"json"},{"id":83,"name":"julian"},{"id":38,"name":"k8s"},{"id":31,"name":"language"},{"id":10,"name":"learning-resource"},{"id":33,"name":"lib"},{"id":41,"name":"linter"},{"id":28,"name":"lms"},{"id":16,"name":"logging"},{"id":76,"name":"low-code"},{"id":90,"name":"message-queue"},{"id":42,"name":"mobile-app"},{"id":18,"name":"monitoring"},{"id":36,"name":"networking"},{"id":7,"name":"node-version"},{"id":55,"name":"nosql"},{"id":57,"name":"observability"},{"id":46,"name":"orm"},{"id":52,"name":"os"},{"id":14,"name":"parser"},{"id":74,"name":"react"},{"id":82,"name":"real-time"},{"id":56,"name":"robot"},{"id":65,"name":"runtime"},{"id":32,"name":"sdk"},{"id":71,"name":"search"},{"id":63,"name":"secrets"},{"id":25,"name":"security"},{"id":85,"name":"server"},{"id":86,"name":"serverless"},{"id":70,"name":"storage"},{"id":75,"name":"system-design"},{"id":79,"name":"terminal"},{"id":29,"name":"testing"},{"id":12,"name":"ui"},{"id":50,"name":"ux"},{"id":88,"name":"video"},{"id":20,"name":"web-app"},{"id":35,"name":"web-server"},{"id":43,"name":"webassembly"},{"id":69,"name":"workflow"},{"id":87,"name":"yaml"}]" returns me the "expected json"